Flavor Guide

Create a flavor combination that's all your own! Explore available flavors and combinations for cakes, cupcakes, cake pops (discs), and cakesicles. Many options can be customized based on your preferences. 

DECORATED SUGAR cookies

Cookie Flavor: Choose one cookie flavor for your entire order, or mix and match flavors by dozen.

Royal Icing Flavor: Choose one icing flavor for your order, or add a second icing flavor for $5 per order. Maximum of two icing flavors per order.

Cookie and royal icing flavors are subject to availability and may vary seasonally.

Cookie Flavors

CORE FLAVORS
Available year-round

Vanilla - classic sugar cookie with a sweet vanilla flavor 

Funfetti - cake-batter flavored sugar cookie packed with colorful sprinkles

Red Velvet - rich red velvet sugar cookie with a hint of cocoa

Cookies 'n Cream - sugar cookie loaded with crushed Oreo cookies 

ROTATING & SEASONAL FLAVORS
Available during select times of the year

Chocolate Chip - classic chocolate chip cookie flavor, loaded with chocolate chips 

Inside Out Chocolate Chip - rich chocolate sugar cookie loaded with white chocolate chips 

Peanut Butter - sugar cookie made with real peanut butter for a rich, classic peanut butter flavor 

Pumpkin Spice - classic sugar cookie infused with warm pumpkin pie spices 

Salted Caramel - caramel-flavored sugar cookie studded with sweet caramel bits and finished with a touch of salt 

Please note: Rotating and seasonal flavors are not always available and may vary based on the current menu and ingredient availability. If you have your heart set on a rotating flavor, feel free to ask when submitting your quote request! 

Royal Icing Flavors

Almond (nut-free)

Cream Cheese

Marshmallow

Princess (Classic bakery flavor with notes of almond, vanilla & citrus)

Vanilla 

Cakes & Cupcakes

Choose your cake or cupcake flavor from the options below. Cupcakes are available in standard or mini size. Premium selections are marked with an asterisk (*).

For cupcakes: Premium selections are priced at the premium cupcake rate.
For custom cakes: Premium selections are priced separately based on the cake.

Cake Flavors

Almond*

Banana*

Carrot*

Chocolate

Dark Chocolate

Checkerboard*

Chocolate Cherry Chip*

Cookies 'n Cream*

Funfetti

Marble

Red Velvet

Spice

Vanilla 

Frosting & Buttercream Flavors

Almond

Chocolate

Chocolate Fudge*

Coconut

Cookies 'n Cream*

Cream Cheese*

Hazelnut

Lemon

Mocha

Peanut Butter

Raspberry

Strawberry

Vanilla

Between-the-Layer Options

All cakes include something between the cake layers. Choose a buttercream flavor listed above or one of the filling options below. 

Banana Custard
Bananas (Fresh*)
Blueberry Fruit Filling
Chocolate Custard
Chocolate Fudge*
Chocolate Ganache*
Lemon Curd*
Raspberry Fruit Filling
Raspberries (Fresh)*
Strawberry Fruit Filling
Strawberries (Fresh)*
Vanilla Custard

Premium Cupcake Combinations  

Andes Mint — Dark chocolate cake with ganache and mint buttercream.

Boston Cream — Yellow cake with vanilla custard and chocolate ganache.

Chocolate Cherry Chip — Cherry chocolate chip cake with vanilla buttercream.

Chocolate Covered Banana — Vanilla cake with banana buttercream and chocolate ganache.

Chocolate Covered Strawberry — Vanilla cake with strawberry buttercream and chocolate ganache.

Cookies 'n Cream — Vanilla cake with Oreo buttercream.

German Chocolate — Chocolate cake with German chocolate frosting and chocolate buttercream.

Lemon Raspberry — Lemon raspberry cake with lemon buttercream.

PB&J — Vanilla cake with strawberry filling and peanut butter buttercream.

Peanut Butter Cup — Chocolate cake with peanut butter buttercream and Reese's Peanut Butter Cups.

Piña Colada — Pineapple rum cake with rum buttercream and coconut.

Red Velvet — Red velvet cake with cream cheese frosting.

S'mores — Chocolate cake with marshmallow frosting, graham crackers, and mini chocolate chips.

Turtle — Chocolate cake with chocolate buttercream, caramel, and pecans.

Cake Pops/discs & Cakesicles 

Cake Pops & Cake Discs — starting at $48/dozen
Cakesicles — starting at $48/dozen

Premium combinations are marked with an asterisk (*) in the Flavor Guide.

Cake Discs & Cakesicle Flavors  

Andes Mint* — Dark chocolate cake with chopped Andes Mint candies and dark chocolate coating.

Birthday Cake — Vanilla sprinkle cake coated in white chocolate with colorful sprinkles.

Carrot Cake* — Carrot cake flavored with cream cheese and coated in white chocolate.

Chocolate Birthday Cake — Chocolate cake coated in milk chocolate with colorful sprinkles.

Chocolate Cherry Chip* — Almond cake with maraschino cherries and mini chocolate chips, coated in dark chocolate.

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough* — Eggless chocolate chip cookie dough coated in milk chocolate.

Chocolate Covered Banana* — Banana cake coated in milk chocolate.

Chocolate Covered Strawberry* — Strawberry cake coated in dark chocolate.

Chocolate Hazelnut* — Chocolate cake with Nutella, coated in milk chocolate.

Chocolate Marshmallow — Chocolate cake flavored with marshmallow and coated in milk chocolate.

Christmas Coal Cake* — Dark chocolate cake with mini chocolate chips, coated in black chocolate.

Classic Chocolate — Chocolate cake coated in milk chocolate.

Classic Vanilla — Vanilla cake coated in white chocolate.

Coconut — Vanilla cake flavored with coconut, coated in white chocolate and coconut.

Cookies 'n Cream* — White cake with Oreo cookies, coated in white chocolate.

Dark Chocolate — Dark chocolate cake coated in dark chocolate.

Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter* — Dark chocolate peanut butter cake with peanut butter chips, coated in dark chocolate.

German Chocolate* — Chocolate cake with coconut and pecans, coated in milk chocolate.

Lemon Vanilla — Vanilla cake flavored with lemon and coated in white chocolate.

Mud Pie* — Chocolate cake flavored with mocha and mixed with Oreo cookies, coated in milk chocolate.

Peanut Butter — White cake with peanut butter, coated in milk chocolate.

Red Velvet — Red velvet cake flavored with cream cheese and coated in white chocolate.

Rolo Ball* — Chocolate cake with a Rolo candy center, coated in milk chocolate.

S'mores* — White cake with marshmallows and chocolate between graham cracker cookies.

Spice Cake — Spice cake flavored with cream cheese and coated in white chocolate.

Strawberry Cream Cheese — Strawberry cake flavored with cream cheese and coated in white chocolate.

Strawberry Upside Down* — Strawberry cake with freeze-dried strawberries, coated in pink chocolate.

Sugar Cookie* — Sugar cookies flavored with cream cheese and coated in white chocolate.

Turtle* — Chocolate cake with caramel and pecans, coated in milk chocolate.

Vanilla Marshmallow — Vanilla cake flavored with marshmallow and coated in white chocolate.

Wedding Cake — Almond cake coated in white chocolate.